Charity Scam

This article has been prompted by the latest Government proposal (Andy Burnham MP) that the NHS be charity run. Do not be  fooled people. Yet another copy of a failed USA system.

Copyright Carol Dimon 2015- with  a bit of Lenin’s magic.

Charities are usually considered  with high regard  by members of the public. They provide such essential care and services; many staff working unpaid. Are charities being used by the wealthy, as a tax free scam that  rely on the  goodwill of public and volunteers?

Over the last few years, the number of Registered charities within the UK  has mushroomed. To be registered as a charity in the UK, it has to earn more than £5000 a year (

Some charities are funded by central or local government. Some Directors are very well paid ; Seamark (2014) states  “Fresh demands to curb the salaries of fat cat charity bosses were made yesterday after it emerged that Save the Children is paying its top employee £234,000 a year”. There are others “Executives at one of the UK’s most prominent international aid charities were handed bonuses worth more than £160,000 last year”  (Ledwith 2013). In 2011 the average salary of charity hospital Directors in the USA was $600,000 with large remuneration for many other members of the hospital board; many of whom are local businesses who tend to win the contracts (Ostrow 2014). Would such human nature not be present in the UK? Are we immune from corruption?

Further,several cases of fraud within charities have been reported, for example in the USA ( According to Wallace Christensen, a minister, started Shiloh International Ministries in 1981. Today, its IRS tax filings list this broad mission statement: “To provide medical necessities and moral support to needy children and to provide assistance to the homeless and hungry, our American veterans, children’s hospItals and Christians in need everywhere.” But the charity has spent little cash on its cause. Over the past decade, it has raised $8 million and paid 78 percent of that to the professional solicitors it hired to find donors. In comparison, the charity spent less than 2 percent of donations on direct cash aid to the needy. In the same period, the charity paid its officers a total of $860,000 — nearly eight times more than the cash it spent on its cause. In 2010, the charity was No. 1 on the Oregon attorney general’s list of worst charities, which ranks organizations based on how little they spend on their charitable causes over a three-year period. Officials at Shiloh did not respond to multiple requests for comment.

Charity hospitals may actually be bought by private businesses (2015) states “California’s largest nurses organization, the California Nurses Association/National Nurses United today issued the following statement on the conditional approval of the sale of six Daughters of Charity Health System (DCHS) hospitals in the Bay Area and Los Angeles that were “on life support,” facing imminent bankruptcy, huge reductions in patient services, and closure”.

”Charities are not required to detail by name how much their top executives are paid, and many express the sums in bands, disguising the true figures” “MPs condemned both the pay rates and the secrecy”- but somebody obviously does not condemn it . Indeed some Charity Directors have previous political roles, for example, the former advisor to Tony Blair (Ledwith 2013).

Regarding lower level staff  few charities pay them the living wage if they are not “volunteers” “About 200 (or 0.1%) of the UK’s 200,000 charities have so far signed up to be living wage employers, according to the Living Wage Foundation (Smedley 2015).
The profit is put back into the charity they say. In the UK charities are able to invest money as long as it “meets the aim of the charity” ( ). Individuals may also purchase charity bonds.  Could some of these individuals be politicians? Politicians are able to invest in private businesses including healthcare (Nightingale 2014). This could well be a conflict of interest. Indeed, in the USA (Kusnetz 2013) discusses such links between politicians and charities – “State lawmakers have used a variety of legislative tools to steer millions in government money to nonprofit groups with whom they’re closely affiliated. Such relationships are at the root of scandals that have ensnared at least eight state legislators in New York”.

Of course errors or malpractice can still occur within charities as it does anywhere for example, bbcnews (2011), Howell (2013), and  Cambridge (2014) within the UK.

Why propose that  the NHS be charity run?

The government  still puts some money in- the rest may be gained by fund raising. But the government is not then responsible for the service. This reflects many government proposals, such as the hiving off of the Manchester NHS. It is like an admiral giving control of the ship to the crew, then blaming them for the shipwreck.

Any complaints need be eventually made to the charity commission if all else fails.  There are separate charity commissions; one  for England and Wales, one for Northern Ireland, and the Scottish Charity Regulator for Scotland.

The USA, New Zealand, and Australia already have many charity run hospitals- many of which are proved to be failing, for example (Carville 2013) discusses  tax exempt status  in New Zealand .

Charities have to return money to the community. “In New Zealand there is a public expectation that if it is a charity it will be charitable but there is no accountability or regulation. It is not good enough. We need to raise the standards as we are way behind,” Gousmett said” (ibid).

Charities are not subject to FOI requests in the UK, so no information has to be provided regarding money and other issues. “Christchurch’s St George’s Hospital, which is run as a charity, made millions of dollars last year but gave back less than $100,000 to the community – an amount slammed by critics as “tokenism” (Carville 2013). The question is, where did the rest of the money go?

Charity owned hospitals in the USA are chasing people for debt- Gold 2012; does this not oppose the public perception of what a charity is? In this way charities are businesses that fund big businesses (Debt collectors). This suits politicians and big businesses.

Any agency that is government or business funded may have gagging clauses ; “Research by the Independence Panel, made up of senior charity experts, found the sector was facing strict contracts controlling what it could say publicly about schemes it was helping to run ( 2014). For example, government funded bodies may be less able to debate against the major political perspective regarding such issues as quality of care. (2015) states that “British charities say they have been targeted in a “subtle” yet “menacing” fashion by prominent political figures for publicly criticizing the coalition’s austerity policies. Others are silenced by gagging clauses in government contracts.” Funding may buy silence. Yet they who are funded are stronger agencies and considered with higher esteem. Are charities  a political means of hiding privatisation?  Weasel words Lenin, weasel words.


40 thoughts on “Charity Scam


    05/03/2015 · Bristol Council has accused a housing charity faced with closure of a catalogue of serious failings.
    Charity Commission ‘failing to check suspicious groups …

    The charity regulator is failing to check all high-risk groups fully and to ensure that taxpayer subsidies for good causes are not being used by criminals or …

    • Food bank Britain: Thousands need charity handouts because … › News › UK

      Food bank Britain: Thousands need charity handouts because of welfare system failings THOUSANDS of people are relying on food banks to survive because of failings …

      Charity cash could end up in the hands of terrorists …

      Charity cash could end up in the hands of terrorists: Watchdog ‘failing to tackle abuses’ Critical report was compiled by the National Audit Office

      Charities ‘are failing to respond’ to changing times

      04/09/2012 · Charities ‘are failing to respond’ to changing times. Your name. … Message. News Charities ‘are failing to respond’ to … can put a charity in a more …

      Charity body ‘is failing on fraud’ – News – The Independent › News

      THE CHARITY Commissioners have been “complacent” about potential fraud and have shown “a lack of management grip” in regulating the sector, a committee of MPs has …

  2. Is the charity sector really failing us? | NCVO Blogs

    NCVO’s Karl Wilding responds to Peter Buffett’s New York Times Op-Ed on the charity-industrial complex

  3. BBC NEWS | Health | Learning disabled ‘failed by NHS’

    The ombudsmen investigated the cases after they were highlighted by the charity Mencap. … It also said the failings in the care of two more – Tom …

  4. NHS still failing patients, claims charity | News | Age UK…/archive/nhs-still-failing-patients-claims-charity

    Although the charity said the NHS has much to be proud of, it claimed the dossier of 13 cases should act as a wake-up call. Bad communication, lack of help going to …

    BBC News – ‘Catastrophic failings’ in schizophrenia care

    14/11/2012 · Charity spokesman Paul Jenkins says stigma is a “massive issue” for people with schizophrenia

  5. NHS charities guidance – Publications – GOV.UK

    Guidance for managing NHS charities in England and Wales. … Guidance for corporate trustees and trustee bodies managing NHS charitable funds … The Charity Commission.

    The Charity Commission – GOV.UK

    Charity Commission News. The latest edition of our newsletter which provides essential information for charity trustees and their advisers. Latest.

    NHS charities guidance – Charity Commission…/nhs-charities-guidance

    NHS charities guidance (February 2012) Contents. INTRODUCTION About the Commission’s guidance to NHS charities. A WHAT IS AN ‘NHS CHARITY’? …

  6. Consultation on draft guidance on NHS charities: glossary…

    Consultation on draft guidance on NHS charities … the Department of Health and the Charity Commission. … (National Health Service Charitable and Non …

  7. King’s College Hospital Charity – King’s College … › … › King’s College Hospital Charity

    King’s College Hospital Charity . King’s College Hospital Charity relies on donations to fund new research, state-of-the-art equipment and the best patient care.

  8. CHARITY LAW ASSOCIATION Response to the Charity Commission … · PDF file

    1 CHARITY LAW ASSOCIATION Response to the Charity Commission’s consultation on the draft guidance “Managing conflicts of interest, a guide to trustees”

  9. Hearsay I know but more reliable than research (!). It seems registered charities are the first point of call for some Local Authorites– out do the little man. Hand in glove.

  10. Charity begins at home, or so it used to be, the fat cat director & CEO’s obviously think that means their homes.
    As for the Charities Commission, it is run for their own interests and if not corrupt, its only because the complaints about them have not been made public.Once been found out yet they will blame the government.
    Round & round the roundabout goes

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s